The Source for Java Technology Collaboration
User: Password:



Start New Message Post a Reply

Subject:  Forking ?
Date:  2006-08-21 10:29:13
From:  bjb
Response to: The license must address the impetus for Open Sourcing Java///


Can you tell me if what IBM has done with their Java SDK is not already "forking" ? And what about Harmony ? Is it different from a fork (on the platform risk ground) ?

Java is not a software !

Java is a platform with specifications, test compatibility kits and a reference implementation.

You can already create your own implementation and if it passes the TCK you can put "Java compatible" on it !
So actually, the same risk of forking are already there with third-party implementation.

A dual license (GPL for source + Java BinaryLicense for binaries) is for me the solution : no changes for enterprises, improvement for the community !

Sun has to opensource the RI and going for a well-known license would ensure Java's success for decades.

If opensource is there, then be sure another famous platform will have a serious problem for the next 5 years. Look, MS did not manage to kill Linux even with billions ! Linux is gaining momentum each days ....

 Feed java.net RSS Feeds